The Good: Jersey Shore. The Bad: Jersey Shore. The Ugly: Jersey Shore.
I reckon that Jersey Shore is the best argument for and against reality television. It satisfies our quest for a voyeuristic entertainment, it replaces the vaudeville freak show, it serves to show off the depraved nature of American society. In a way, you could say it is the perfect entertainment for the dystopian now. It is independent of timeline, you can air episodes daily, or weekly and it would not matter. It would gain repeat viewers, no matter what. People would love it, people would hate it. It is win win for the networks.
The sane part of me loves and hates reality television at the same time. I love it because I see the potential for the medium. It can inspire and elevate the viewers. I hate it because I see the failed potential. It caters to the average, and provides cheap laughs and potty humor. I also see the financial side to it. It makes financial sense to show this stuff on network television. Just because people would watch it, for fun, or to be grossed out. And that means money, lots of it. It is a definite win for the corporations, and I see that too. Reality TV is just a paradox in a paradox.